Should I trade Frankie Montas for Carlos Carrasco?

See our analysis of a proposed trade of Frankie Montas for Carlos Carrasco.

Register for free to get analysis using your league's scoring and roster settings!

Change Players in Trade Analysis

Select Player(s) to Trade Away

Select Player(s) to Trade For

Strong Recommendation

Frankie Montas

Change Player

Carlos Carrasco

Change Player

CIN · SP

CLE · SP

Pitching
Rest of Season Projections
Trade Value	0.30	-0.16
FPTS	164.00	111.00

W	6	4
L	8	6
SV	0	0
IP	105.1	98.2
H	103	106
ER	50	56
K	97	79
BB	37	36
ERA	4.28	5.18
WHIP	1.34	1.45

Most Recent and Popular Comparisons
	Trade Frankie Montas for Luke Weaver Trade Frankie Montas for JP Sears Trade Frankie Montas for Erick Fedde Trade Frankie Montas for Lance Lynn Trade Frankie Montas for Jake Irvin	Trade Carlos Carrasco for Michael Grove Trade Carlos Carrasco for Clayton Kershaw Trade Carlos Carrasco for Keaton Winn Trade Carlos Carrasco for Joe Ross Trade Carlos Carrasco for Matt Liberatore

Pitching
Season Statistics
FPTS	38.0	39.0
W	2	2
L	3	3
SV	0	0
IP	30.0	40.1
H	29	43
ER	14	24
K	24	31
BB	12	17
ERA	4.20	5.39
WHIP	1.37	1.50

Recent News
	Reds activate TJ Friedl, Frankie Montas ahead of series opener against Diamondbacks Published May 13th, 2024 via MSN Reds' Frankie Montas: No-decision Sunday Published May 12th, 2024 via CBS Sports Breaking down Frankie Montas' pitches \| 05/12/2024 \| Cincinnati Reds Published May 12th, 2024 via MLB.com Frankie Montas will take the mound as the Reds look to take the series against the Giants Published May 12th, 2024 via Athlon Sports Reds, Frankie Montas look for series win against San Francisco's young ace Kyle Harrison Published May 12th, 2024 via The Cincinnati Enquirer Frankie Montas thrives in return from injured list - Cincinnati Published May 8th, 2024 via MLB.com Frankie Montas excellent in return from IL Published May 8th, 2024 via FantasyPros Reds' Frankie Montas: Stuck with loss in return Published May 7th, 2024 via CBS Sports	Carlos Carrasco stumbles again, Guardians fall to White Sox Published May 11th, 2024 via FantasyPros Carlos Carrasco shines in Guardians' tough loss to White Sox, shows improvement in recent starts Published May 10th, 2024 via BVM Sports Carlos Carrasco goes seven innings in Guardians' loss Published May 10th, 2024 via MLB.com Guardians' Carlos Carrasco: Stumbles in loss Published May 10th, 2024 via CBS Sports Guardians' Carlos Carrasco: Bounces back with W Published May 5th, 2024 via CBS Sports Carlos Carrasco earns win Sunday Published May 5th, 2024 via FantasyPros Celebrating Carlos Carrasco's first Cleveland win since 2020 Published May 2nd, 2024 via Audacy Carlos Carrasco Injury: Updates on Indians Pitcher's Finger and Recovery Published May 1st, 2024 via Bleacher Report

Rest of Season Schedule
Tue May 14	@ ARI Pitcher: Cecconi	@ TEX Pitcher: Leiter
Wed May 15	@ ARI Pitcher: Pfaadt	@ TEX Pitcher: Gray
Thu May 16	@ LAD Pitcher: Glasnow
Fri May 17	@ LAD Pitcher: Paxton	vs. MIN Pitcher: Woods Richardson
Sat May 18	@ LAD Pitcher: Buehler	vs. MIN Pitcher: Ober
Sun May 19	@ LAD Pitcher: Yamamoto	vs. MIN Pitcher: Paddack
Mon May 20		vs. NYM Pitcher: Quintana
Tue May 21	vs. SD Pitcher: King	vs. NYM Pitcher: Scott
Wed May 22	vs. SD Pitcher: Waldron	vs. NYM Pitcher: Severino
Thu May 23	vs. SD Pitcher: Darvish
Fri May 24	vs. LAD Pitcher: Buehler	@ LAA Pitcher: Sandoval
Sat May 25	vs. LAD	@ LAA
Sun May 26	vs. LAD	@ LAA
Mon May 27	vs. STL	@ COL
Tue May 28	vs. STL	@ COL
Wed May 29	vs. STL	@ COL
Fri May 31	@ CHC	vs. WSH
Sat Jun 1	@ CHC	vs. WSH
Sun Jun 2	@ CHC	vs. WSH
Mon Jun 3	@ COL
Tue Jun 4	@ COL	vs. KC
Wed Jun 5	@ COL	vs. KC
Thu Jun 6	vs. CHC	vs. KC
Fri Jun 7	vs. CHC	@ MIA
Sat Jun 8	vs. CHC	@ MIA
Sun Jun 9	vs. CHC	@ MIA
Tue Jun 11	vs. CLE	@ CIN
Wed Jun 12	vs. CLE	@ CIN
Fri Jun 14	@ MIL	@ TOR
Sat Jun 15	@ MIL	@ TOR
Sun Jun 16	@ MIL	@ TOR
Mon Jun 17	@ PIT
Tue Jun 18	@ PIT	vs. SEA
Wed Jun 19	@ PIT	vs. SEA
Thu Jun 20		vs. SEA
Fri Jun 21	vs. BOS	vs. TOR
Sat Jun 22	vs. BOS	vs. TOR
Sun Jun 23	vs. BOS	vs. TOR
Mon Jun 24	vs. PIT	@ BAL
Tue Jun 25	vs. PIT	@ BAL
Wed Jun 26	vs. PIT	@ BAL
Thu Jun 27	@ STL	@ KC
Fri Jun 28	@ STL	@ KC
Sat Jun 29	@ STL	@ KC
Sun Jun 30	@ STL	@ KC
Tue Jul 2	@ NYY	vs. CHW
Wed Jul 3	@ NYY	vs. CHW
Thu Jul 4	@ NYY	vs. CHW
Fri Jul 5	vs. DET	vs. SF
Sat Jul 6	vs. DET	vs. SF
Sun Jul 7	vs. DET	vs. SF
Mon Jul 8	vs. COL	@ DET
Tue Jul 9	vs. COL	@ DET
Wed Jul 10	vs. COL	@ DET
Thu Jul 11	vs. COL	@ DET
Fri Jul 12	vs. MIA	@ TB
Sat Jul 13	vs. MIA	@ TB
Sun Jul 14	vs. MIA	@ TB
Fri Jul 19	@ WSH	vs. SD
Sat Jul 20	@ WSH	vs. SD
Sun Jul 21	@ WSH	vs. SD
Mon Jul 22	@ ATL	vs. DET
Tue Jul 23	@ ATL	vs. DET
Wed Jul 24	@ ATL	vs. DET
Thu Jul 25		vs. DET
Fri Jul 26	@ TB	@ PHI
Sat Jul 27	@ TB	@ PHI
Sun Jul 28	@ TB	@ PHI
Mon Jul 29	vs. CHC	@ DET
Tue Jul 30	vs. CHC	@ DET
Wed Jul 31	vs. CHC
Thu Aug 1		vs. BAL
Fri Aug 2	vs. SF	vs. BAL
Sat Aug 3	vs. SF	vs. BAL
Sun Aug 4	vs. SF	vs. BAL
Mon Aug 5	@ MIA	vs. ARI
Tue Aug 6	@ MIA	vs. ARI
Wed Aug 7	@ MIA	vs. ARI
Thu Aug 8	@ MIA
Fri Aug 9	@ MIL	@ MIN
Sat Aug 10	@ MIL	@ MIN
Sun Aug 11	@ MIL	@ MIN
Mon Aug 12	vs. STL	vs. CHC
Tue Aug 13	vs. STL	vs. CHC
Wed Aug 14	vs. STL	vs. CHC
Fri Aug 16	vs. KC	@ MIL
Sat Aug 17	vs. KC	@ MIL
Sun Aug 18	vs. KC	@ MIL
Mon Aug 19	@ TOR
Tue Aug 20	@ TOR	@ NYY
Wed Aug 21	@ TOR	@ NYY
Thu Aug 22	@ PIT	@ NYY
Fri Aug 23	@ PIT	vs. TEX
Sat Aug 24	@ PIT	vs. TEX
Sun Aug 25	@ PIT	vs. TEX
Mon Aug 26		vs. KC
Tue Aug 27	vs. OAK	vs. KC
Wed Aug 28	vs. OAK	vs. KC
Thu Aug 29	vs. OAK
Fri Aug 30	vs. MIL	vs. PIT
Sat Aug 31	vs. MIL	vs. PIT
Sun Sep 1	vs. MIL	vs. PIT
Mon Sep 2	vs. HOU	@ KC
Tue Sep 3		@ KC
Wed Sep 4	vs. HOU	@ KC
Thu Sep 5	vs. HOU
Fri Sep 6	@ NYM	@ LAD
Sat Sep 7	@ NYM	@ LAD
Sun Sep 8	@ NYM	@ LAD
Mon Sep 9		@ CHW
Tue Sep 10	@ STL	@ CHW
Wed Sep 11	@ STL	@ CHW
Thu Sep 12	@ STL	vs. TB
Fri Sep 13	@ MIN	vs. TB
Sat Sep 14	@ MIN	vs. TB
Sun Sep 15	@ MIN	vs. TB
Mon Sep 16		vs. MIN
Tue Sep 17	vs. ATL	vs. MIN
Wed Sep 18	vs. ATL	vs. MIN
Thu Sep 19	vs. ATL	vs. MIN
Fri Sep 20	vs. PIT	@ STL
Sat Sep 21	vs. PIT	@ STL
Sun Sep 22	vs. PIT	@ STL
Tue Sep 24	@ CLE	vs. CIN
Wed Sep 25	@ CLE	vs. CIN
Fri Sep 27	@ CHC	vs. HOU
Sat Sep 28	@ CHC	vs. HOU
Sun Sep 29	@ CHC	vs. HOU

New Seasons Now Available

Free Tools

Use our free tools to become a fantasy expert and dominate your league!

Get started in seconds
Sync unlimited leagues for free - no paywalls!
Customized for your league, roster and scoring settings
Support for football, baseball, basketball and hockey
Roto and point-based support
Live Draft Syncing
Draft decision analysis
Intuitive Mock Drafts
Insights on H2H matchups
Most scoring statistics supported
No manual entry required
Much, much more!!

Browser Extension

Highest Player Projections

Preseason
Jalen Hurts (PHI)	348
Christian McCaffrey (SF)	347
Josh Allen (BUF)	339
Patrick Mahomes (KC)	338
CeeDee Lamb (DAL)	334
Breece Hall (NYJ)	318
Tyreek Hill (MIA)	315
Lamar Jackson (BAL)	304
Dak Prescott (DAL)	302
Ja'Marr Chase (CIN)	297
Amon-Ra St. Brown (DET)	296
Justin Jefferson (MIN)	293
C.J. Stroud (HOU)	281
Joe Burrow (CIN)	280
Bijan Robinson (ATL)	279
A.J. Brown (PHI)	278
Jayden Daniels (WSH)	277
Caleb Williams (CHI)	277
Brock Purdy (SF)	276

End of Season Results
Nikola Jokic (DEN)	4820.3
Luka Doncic (DAL)	4618.0
Giannis Antetokounmpo (MIL)	4328.0
Domantas Sabonis (SAC)	4320.0
Anthony Davis (LAL)	4052.8
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (OKC)	3884.3
LeBron James (LAL)	3613.5
Jayson Tatum (BOS)	3579.5
Victor Wembanyama (SA)	3567.3
Jalen Brunson (NY)	3530.5
Kevin Durant (PHX)	3523.8
Anthony Edwards (MIN)	3468.0
De'Aaron Fox (SAC)	3401.0
Paolo Banchero (ORL)	3345.0
Dejounte Murray (ATL)	3332.3
Tyrese Haliburton (IND)	3204.8
DeMar DeRozan (CHI)	3204.0
Stephen Curry (GS)	3185.0
Damian Lillard (MIL)	3148.5

Today (5/14)
Dylan Cease (SD)	18.60
Ronel Blanco (HOU)	15.97
Chris Sale (ATL)	15.70
Sonny Gray (STL)	15.54
Logan Gilbert (SEA)	15.41
Aaron Nola (PHI)	13.25
Mitchell Parker (WSH)	12.35
Jameson Taillon (CHC)	12.06
Slade Cecconi (ARI)	11.66
Kyle Bradish (BAL)	11.56
Nick Pivetta (BOS)	11.43
Erick Fedde (CHW)	10.95
Gavin Stone (LAD)	10.87
Reid Detmers (LAA)	10.63
Reese Olson (DET)	10.48
Carlos Rodon (NYY)	10.01
Hunter Greene (CIN)	9.17
Jose Butto (NYM)	8.58
Aaron Civale (TB)	8.44

End of Season Results
Nathan MacKinnon (COL)	1262
Auston Matthews (TOR)	1112
Nikita Kucherov (TB)	1096
Connor McDavid (EDM)	1027
David Pastrnak (BOS)	1011
Artemi Panarin (NYR)	990
Filip Forsberg (NSH)	924
Mikko Rantanen (COL)	909
Sam Reinhart (FLA)	893
Kirill Kaprizov (MIN)	870
Roman Josi (NSH)	868
Cale Makar (COL)	866
J.T. Miller (VAN)	864
William Nylander (TOR)	857
Leon Draisaitl (EDM)	856
Zach Hyman (EDM)	826
Sidney Crosby (PIT)	806
Evan Bouchard (EDM)	805
Quinn Hughes (VAN)	789

Most Added Players

Greg Zuerlein (NYJ)	+69.96%
Anthony Richardson (IND)	+69.32%
Ka'imi Fairbairn (HOU)	+68.96%
Nick Chubb (CLE)	+64.77%
Aaron Rodgers (NYJ)	+60.94%
Joe Burrow (CIN)	+56.03%
Mike Williams (NYJ)	+54.76%
Tank Dell (HOU)	+53.76%
Mark Andrews (BAL)	+44.76%
Darnell Mooney (ATL)	+44.58%

Chet Holmgren (OKC)	+1.17%
Kevin Durant (PHX)	+0.99%
Tyrese Maxey (PHI)	+0.76%
Paul George (LAC)	+0.35%
Stephen Curry (GS)	+0.28%
DeMar DeRozan (CHI)	+0.28%
Damian Lillard (MIL)	+0.24%
Jimmy Butler (MIA)	+0.19%
Anthony Davis (LAL)	+0.13%
LeBron James (LAL)	+0.13%

Kyle Manzardo (CLE)	+56.37%
Christian Scott (NYM)	+48.84%
Paul Skenes (PIT)	+43.06%
Robert Gasser (MIL)	+39.47%
Jack Leiter (TEX)	+35.95%
Brent Rooker (OAK)	+30.57%
Mike Clevinger (CHW)	+28.06%
Tyler Soderstrom (OAK)	+26.24%
Mason Black (SF)	+25.77%
Abraham Toro (OAK)	+23.03%

Jake Walman (DET)	+29.58%
Colton Parayko (STL)	+28.32%
Brayden McNabb (VGS)	+27.44%
David Savard (MTL)	+27.15%
Adam Larsson (SEA)	+23.51%
Matt Roy (LA)	+23.08%
Ben Chiarot (DET)	+23.05%
Rafael Harvey-Pinard (MTL)	+22.92%
Ryan Graves (PIT)	+22.89%
Jeff Petry (DET)	+22.25%

Player News

Caleb Williams (CHI)
Chicago Bears soar in ESPN's rankings with Caleb Williams and talented additions
BVM Sports
Malik Nabers (NYG)
Fantasy Football Rookies: Marvin Harrison Jr., Malik Nabers, Ladd McConkey
FantasyPros
Dorian Thompson-Robinson (CLE)
Browns QB Named Among Top Trade Candidates
Heavy.com
Phillip Dorsett (DEN)
Broncos Re-Sign Phillip Dorsett
Chase Brown (CIN)
Fantasy Football Position Battles: Zack Moss & Chase Brown
FantasyPros
Bo Nix (DEN)
"Bo Nix Is the Exact Opposite of Russell Wilson": Sean Payton Impressed as Broncos Insider Analyzes Rookie QB's ...
EssentiallySports
Josh Downs (IND)
Film Room: Josh Downs
The Blue Stable
Bo Nix (DEN)
'Really Freaking Fast': Bo Nix Already Getting Rave Reviews From Teammates
MSN

Jaylen Brown (BOS)
Jaylen Brown Gets It Done In Game 4
Caris LeVert (CLE)
Caris LeVert Can't Lead Cleveland To A Win
Mitchell Robinson (NY)
Mitchell Robinson Undergoes Another Ankle Procedure
Derrick White (BOS)
Derrick White Fizzles Offensively Versus Cleveland
Evan Mobley (CLE)
Evan Mobley Just Misses A Double-Double On Monday
Darius Garland (CLE)
Darius Garland Has A Big Night On Monday
Max Strus (CLE)
Max Strus Plays Well In Game 4
Jrue Holiday (BOS)
Jrue Holiday Looks Great On Monday Night

Brooks Raley (NYM)
Brooks Raley's Season Is In Jeopardy
David Peterson (NYM)
David Peterson Moving To Double-A During Rehab
Jose Ramirez (CLE)
Jose Ramirez Collects Four RBI, Steals Two Bases Monday
Tylor Megill (NYM)
Tylor Megill Could Be On Verge Of A Return
Drew Smith (NYM)
Drew Smith Expected To Return This Week
Ryan Pepiot (TB)
Ryan Pepiot Throws Bullpen Session
DJ LeMahieu (NYY)
DJ LeMahieu Could Be Close To Rehab Assignment
Lou Trivino (NYY)
Lou Trivino Still Shut Down

Jordan Martinook (CAR)
Jordan Martinook's true feelings after Hurricanes' Game 5 win vs. Rangers
ClutchPoints
Carson Soucy (VAN)
Former Canucks goalie calls for action on Zach Hyman following Carson Soucy's suspension
MSN
Wyatt Johnston (DAL)
Wyatt Johnston scores twice as Stars push Avs to brink of elimination with 5-1 win in Game 4
KSAT San Antonio
Zach Hyman (EDM)
Former Canucks goalie calls for action on Zach Hyman following Carson Soucy's suspension
MSN
Valeri Nichushkin (COL)
LeBrun: Valeri Nichushkin suspension presents no easy answer for Avalanche
The New York Times
Alexandar Georgiev (COL)
Alexandar Georgiev with a Goalie Save vs. Dallas Stars
Yahoo Canada Sports
Jacob Trouba (NYR)
"We're facing a little adversity": Jacob Trouba doesn't mince words while addressing Rangers third period collapse in ...
Sportskeeda
Valeri Nichushkin (COL)
MARK KISZLA: You can feel sorry for Valeri NIchushkin, but Avs were foolish to trust a player battling demons
The Denver Gazette

Should I trade Frankie Montas for Carlos Carrasco?

See our analysis of a proposed trade of Frankie Montas for Carlos Carrasco.

Select Player(s) to Trade Away

Select Player(s) to Trade For

Trust Us! This Is A