Should I draft Josh Naylor or Pete Alonso?

See our analysis of the choice to draft Josh Naylor or Pete Alonso.

PLEASE NOTE this is a draft choice comparison analysis based upon Preseason Projections only. As the baseball season is already underway, you may instead prefer to view our breakdown of a trade for these players which is based upon several more factors including in-season performance.

Change Players in Draft Analysis

Select Player to Draft

Strong Recommendation

Josh Naylor

Change Player

Pete Alonso

Change Player

CLE · 1B,DH

NYM · 1B

Batting
2024 Preseason Projections
Draft Value	2.82	6.97
ADP	129.12	26.49
PROJ	351.00	405.00
AB	507	562
R	60	88
H	144	134
2B	33	24
3B	0	1
HR	20	40
RBI	90	109
SB	7	3
K	83	138
BB	40	63
AVG	.284	.238
OBP	.339	.320
SLG	.468	.498
OPS	.806	.819

Most Recent and Popular Comparisons
	Draft Josh Naylor or Josh Bell Draft Josh Naylor or Rhys Hoskins Draft Josh Naylor or Spencer Steer Draft Josh Naylor or Anthony Volpe Draft Josh Naylor or Daulton Varsho	Draft Pete Alonso or Ian Happ Draft Pete Alonso or Yandy Diaz Draft Pete Alonso or Austin Riley Draft Pete Alonso or Sean Murphy Draft Pete Alonso or Gunnar Henderson

Batting
Season Statistics
PROJ	185.0	165.0
AB	245	271
R	36	39
H	56	63
2B	9	17
3B	0	0
HR	17	15
RBI	50	37
SB	3	1
K	47	63
BB	27	26
AVG	.229	.233
OBP	.314	.310
SLG	.474	.461
OPS	.788	.772

Recent News
	Josh Naylor to be presented with Tip O'Neill Award Published June 16th, 2024 via StratfordToday Guardians' Josh Naylor: Goes deep in win Published June 12th, 2024 via CBS Sports Josh Naylor BREAKS SLUMP & Tyler Freeman's glove shines in Cleveland Guardians win over Reds Published June 12th, 2024 via WKYC.com Guardians extend win streak, beat Reds behind Josh Naylor, Steven Kwan and solid pitching Published June 11th, 2024 via AOL Josh Naylor's 17th homer, Tyler Freeman's spectacular catches lift Guardians to 5-3 win over Reds Published June 11th, 2024 via The Associated Press Josh Naylor's bat, Tyler Freeman's glove lead Guardians over Reds Published June 11th, 2024 via The Gazette Josh Naylor's 17th homer, Tyler Freeman's spectacular catches lift Guardians to 5-3 win over Reds Published June 11th, 2024 via Yahoo Sports Josh Naylor, Steven Kwan lead Guardians to win over Reds Published June 11th, 2024 via Akron Beacon Journal	Should the Twins try to acquire Pete Alonso? Published June 17th, 2024 via Athlon Sports Pete Alonso's Timely Hitting Propels Mets To Sweep Published June 17th, 2024 via metsmerizedonline.com Should the New York Mets Keep Or Trade Pete Alonso? - WTMM 104.5 The Team Published June 17th, 2024 via ESPN Radio Mets Could Follow Rival's Strategy With Trade Involving Pete Alonso Published June 17th, 2024 via Sports Illustrated Francisco Lindor, Pete Alonso both homer in the 1st \| 06/16/2024 Published June 16th, 2024 via MLB.com Pete Alonso has season-high 5 RBIs as surging Mets beat Padres 11-6 for 5th straight win Published June 16th, 2024 via Rome Sentinel Mets' Pete Alonso: Homers, drives in five Published June 16th, 2024 via CBS Sports Alonso has season-high five RBIs as surging Mets beat Padres for fifth straight win Published June 16th, 2024 via TSN

New Seasons Now Available

Free Tools

Use our free tools to become a fantasy expert and dominate your league!

Get started in seconds
Sync unlimited leagues for free - no paywalls!
Customized for your league, roster and scoring settings
Support for football, baseball, basketball and hockey
Roto and point-based support
Live Draft Syncing
Draft decision analysis
Intuitive Mock Drafts
Insights on H2H matchups
Most scoring statistics supported
No manual entry required
Much, much more!!

Browser Extension